ESG and SRI are two acronyms used for ethical investing. Thanks to the recent surge in ethical investing the Belgian bank NewB found enough investors to get all the funds to receive a banking license. This makes them the first bank focusing mainly on ethical investing and banking. What started as an idea in the aftermath of the financial crisis to change banking forever, much as the crisis did, is now a bank with a license. Ethical investing is taking off!
But it’s not only banks that are trying to become more “ethical”, the range of trackers that receive the label ‘ethical’ or ‘sustainable’ is increasing, but the difference with normal trackers is not always large. It is these trackers that I want to tackle as it’s what most of us trying to achieve FIRE, look at. An overview.
What is 'ethical' investing?
As global warming becomes more and more obvious, the interest in green, sustainable, ethical investments is increasing. But what is ethical investing?
It is investing in a sustainable, ethical, or green approach and looking for double profit: financial for the investor and progress for society. By investing in companies or projects that pay attention to the environment, social policy, and good governance, these companies are rewarded and encouraged to continue in that direction.
That’s the theory, but in practice, a single definition is difficult to provide. What one considers ethical, might not be for the other. This is not helped by the lack of clear rules and regulations in this area. Marketers make smart use of terms such as ‘responsible’, ‘ethical’, ‘ESG’ (Environmental, Social and Governance), ‘impact’.
Usually, they are used as buzz words to draw your attention away from the facts. It’s important to check the investment policy of a particular fund before you buy it to make sure they are genuine. Don’t just rely on the name of the tracker/fund. Besides, traditional funds are also become more ethical, for example, by excluding gun producers.
Ethical vs. 'ethical'
Your conscience may be soothed if your bank adviser tells you that your money does not flow to weapons, hookers, or gambling. But have you ever considered the question which fund your adviser offers to the next customer? Perhaps an investment product in which the sustainability criteria do not count at all. What is the impact of your individual choice? Where do you draw the line?
Some, like Geert Noels, founder of Econopolis (Cleeren, 2018), argue that you should only work with true ethical banks (think NewB) and that banks should make their complete offering ethical and sustainable. Only if you go full force into sustainable investments can you create a lever with which you can have an impact.
Others are less strict for one simple reason. The largest providers of sustainable socially responsible investing (SRI) products in Belgium are precisely the large banks, which offer “regular investments” as well as “regular investments”. If investors dropped out there, 80 percent of the sustainable investment in our country would disappear. (Cleeren, 2018)
How can you invest ethically?
The most traditional way of sustainable investment is to exclude harmful or unwanted activities (fossil fuels, child labor …). The more modern approach to sustainable investing happens through the screening of companies on their environmental impact, their social behavior, and whether they manage well and transparently (the ‘ESG’ criteria, see the clarification below). funds and banks screen funds per sector on these criteria, which also makes it possible to invest in companies that do their best with difficult activities such as chemicals or industry. This “best in class” approach has the advantage that a large diversification of the portfolio remains possible.
Ethical investing principals
There are two types of large indexes. These work according to the ESG principle (environmental, social and governance) or according to the SRI principle (socially responsible investment).
In the highlight below, you can learn the difference. In the name of the tracker, you can see the principle on which the listed investment fund works, SRI, or ESG.
It is also important to confirm the company’s commitment to ethical practices. What they say and what they do can be two different things. you should be careful when looking into which investments you want to avoid and which are interesting. Your own due diligence is essential to determine whether an investment matches your own ethics; Especially when investing in an index or tracker. This will determine if you are really ethical investing or just being played along.
Being ethical pays off
Interesting to note: both the tracker from Amundi and iShares (which are listed below), at first sight, have the same index as the benchmark. the MSCI Europe SRI index. But looks can be deceiving. Amundi works with the 5% capped index. that is, a percentage may have a higher weight than 5%. With iShares has changed its benchmark since last week to MSCI Europe SRI Select Reduced Fossil Fuel index. Companies active in oil sands and oil and gas, for example, will probably see their weight decrease in the future.
Interestingly enough, with the American index of MSCI there is virtually no difference in performance between the MSCI USA and the MSCI USA SRI indexes. The difference is also small between the MSCI World and MSCI World SRI. The difference between the MSCI World and MSCI World SRI is also rather small.
Whether this is because the theme plays less of a role in the US, or are there other explanations? Perhaps a large part of the explanation lies with the technology companies. Since these companies are also sustainable, they can be found in both indexes. For the MSCI Emerging Markets, on the other hand, there is sometimes a clear out-performance for a sustainable index.
Just like there are trackers on large indexes, there are also trackers that respond to a specific theme within ESG or SRI. In the list below I give you examples of ETFs that invest ethical, either ESG or SRI:
Adriaen, D. (2020). NewB heeft banklicentie binnen. [online] De Tijd. Available at: https://www.tijd.be/nieuws/archief/newb-heeft-banklicentie-binnen/10205057 [Accessed 6 Mar. 2020].
Adriaen, D. (2019). Jaar van de waarheid voor ethisch bankproject NewB. [online] De Tijd. Retrieved from https://www.tijd.be/nieuws/archief/Jaar-van-de-waarheid-voor-ethisch-bankproject-NewB/10092396 [Accessed 6 Mar. 2020].
Cleeren, E. (2018). Duurzaam beleggen in 6 stappen. [online] De Tijd. Retrieved from https://www.tijd.be/netto/dossier/duurzaamlevengids/duurzaam-beleggen-in-6-stappen/10004458.html [Accessed 6 Mar. 2020].